• Before posting anything about the COVID-19 virus, please read this first Click Here

Video Truther Doctors are speaking out about COVID-19

Charlottesweb

PI Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2020
Messages
3,677
Likes
821
Why the heck do you keep attempting to shoot the messenger - bringing up the fact that the link is a pro life site discredits your argument, it makes it look like you are attempting to cancel the author rather than debating. When the author attempts to find hard data by producing Police records you actually condemn him for not having more detailed data for the wider population. Total shoot the messenger stuff.

The fact of the matter is that Covid has been pretty much eliminated from this Mumbai slum.
This eradication has coincided with the government of the local state (Maharashtra) mandating HCQ as a prophylactic for its front line workers and with the local Mumbai government (BMC) setting up Covid Care Centres where people suspected of carrying Covid are being as standard given a course of HCQ.

Now you can nitpick that seeing Covid eliminated is coincidental with the administration of HCQ if you like but many other people will look at this and see that as a recommendation of widespread HCQ use even if only based on there being a chance of it being the magic silver bullet we are looking for at very little cost and with no downside if it doesnt work.

Heres another messenger saying the same thing as the previous link. Im sure you will immediately start scrutinising for shootability.


High-risk kin of Maharashtra patients, all ground staff to get HCQS | Mumbai News - Times of India
The reason i nitpicked this is because the story has a quote attributing the eradication of covid in the area to HQ but the quote in question was not saying that at all. But it was presented as such. This is despite there being another quote in the story attributing the success to tracking / tracung and isolating patients.

Its a dishonest version of events and that dishonesty is informed by the agenda of the site. This is why i mentioned that the site is specifically a pro life site by its own admission.
 

Charlottesweb

PI Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2020
Messages
3,677
Likes
821
Heres another messenger saying the same thing as the previous link. Im sure you will immediately start scrutinising for shootability.


High-risk kin of Maharashtra patients, all ground staff to get HCQS | Mumbai News - Times of India
This link is not evidence of anything other than they are handing out HQ as a prophylactic in india to frontline workers. Its up to them if they want to do it, its cheap and a safe enough drug. Whether it works or is the actual cause of a reduced death rate we wont know unless all other variables can be eliminated, which they cannot in this setting
 

Charlottesweb

PI Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2020
Messages
3,677
Likes
821
What resources is HQ taking up? It is an ultra cheap and simple to administer medication. The cost of administering it is insignificant in relation to the total cost of this epidemic.
Resources in terms of scientists wasting time carrying out studies on it. There are many other existing drugs that should be looked at
 

TheWexfordInn

Donator
PI Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2015
Messages
6,161
Likes
9,080
The reason i nitpicked this is because the story has a quote attributing the eradication of covid in the area to HQ but the quote in question was not saying that at all. But it was presented as such. This is despite there being another quote in the story attributing the success to tracking / tracung and isolating patients.

Its a dishonest version of events and that dishonesty is informed by the agenda of the site. This is why i mentioned that the site is specifically a pro life site by its own admission.
The point of the tracking and tracing regime in Mumbai is to identify people who are at risk of carrying Covid to direct them to quarantine in the Covid Care Centres they set up where the standard treatment is to hand out a course of HCQ.
Incidentally they are now closing down their Covid Care Centres due to the precipitous drop in people requiring quarantine.

Now as I said you can argue that Correlation is not Causation and that the widespread use of HCQ in those suspected of carrying Covid and the elimination of the disease is co-incidental but in light if the microscopic cost and low risk of this treatment many or most people would think its worth a go.
 

TheWexfordInn

Donator
PI Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2015
Messages
6,161
Likes
9,080
Resources in terms of scientists wasting time carrying out studies on it. There are many other existing drugs that should be looked at
What other existing drugs are cheap and have the extensive body of "anecdotal" evidence of success that HCQ has?
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpc

M1A2

PI Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2020
Messages
2,232
Likes
488
If these doctors have the cure, they should provide the following information :
:
1. The appropriate dosages depending on the stage of disease, the age and health of the patient, etc
2. Details of the number of patients treated. Full information as to their symptoms, and severity of same at the outset
3. Details of the number of patients cured. Full info as to their symptoms all through the disease and how long they took to recover
4. Details of hospitalisations and other interventions

Basically, if they want to be taken seriously, they should provide the data. A cheap publicity stunt like this is not going to accomplish anything.

Have they approached the FDA or other doctors with their data? Doctors are scientists, if they are presented with verifiable data they will be won over. Why have they not done this?

Did we get any answers to these questions?
 

M1A2

PI Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2020
Messages
2,232
Likes
488
Stay calm don't panic ;-) It's time we face the facts about the Covid scam and demand our governments and media fraudsters stop lying. There's an evil agenda at play and it needs to be confronted. Our liberty and the liberty of the young and future generations needs to be defended.

Stella Immanuel ??
FFS!
 

TheWexfordInn

Donator
PI Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2015
Messages
6,161
Likes
9,080
Dexamethasone and Interferon beta have had promising results
Show me some medical personal who have administered these in the field and are claiming that they have saved thousands of lives ?
There aren't any,
Dexamethasone is claimed to be effective for people on their death beds after they have already cost the Health System an arm and a leg. HCQ it is claimed will stop people endearing up on their death bed in the first place with minimal cost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpc

jpc

PI Member
Joined
May 7, 2018
Messages
4,365
Likes
6,328
Show me some medical personal who have administered these in the field and are claiming that they have saved thousands of lives ?
There aren't any,
Dexamethasone is claimed to be effective for people on their death beds after they have already cost the Health System an arm and a leg. HCQ it is claimed will stop people endearing up on their death bed in the first place with minimal cost.
And that in a nutshell is what it's all about.
Fuck the political angle and the frankly pretty obvious hit job by big pharma
It's about and only about giving people and medical professionals an option to take the edge off a very nasty virus that's going to be around for a long time.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom