I wouldn't even sink that low..

Tadhg Gaelach

Donator
Premium Account
PI Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2016
Threads
1,239
Messages
31,800
Likes
30,591
#3
So he wants to be a public figure but he does not want anything made public.

That's true, but he has stepped down from public office. I don't know how the ISIS Times imagines that it is in the public interest to know his medical details. It sounds like gutter journalism to me.
 
Joined
Nov 26, 2016
Threads
27
Messages
835
Likes
883
Location
earth
#4
McGuinness was entitled to a private life until he considered otherwise. Many public figures battle illness only to be publicised at a later date. We're all human and chances are many of us will battle some serious illness in later life. We get a mere 80 years on this rock.

The irish times should be ashamed.
 

Dan Óg

Ui Máine
Staff member
Moderator
Donator
PI Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Threads
80
Messages
12,486
Likes
6,534
#5
The Irish Times should be commended. Nobody asked him to be a public figure. I want to see a body scan of Michael Obama and I want to know what disease Bill Clinton has also.
 
Joined
Mar 17, 2016
Threads
67
Messages
6,121
Likes
9,367
Location
The land of the golden potato
#6
If he's suffering from some severe health issue then that should be disclosed -- or he should resign from his public role. Or a deputy can be appointed if the roadmap to recovery can occur within a reasonable timeframe. Severe health issues impair judgement in discharging one's public duty effectively. It's an example of a private problem intruding on the public role thus making the problem a public one. The public are entitled to be informed when that happens.

 
Joined
Feb 13, 2016
Threads
1
Messages
24
Likes
15
#7
In general I would agree that a politician's health is his/her own business only. I know America has a different view these days but not long ago it was their view too, like when Roosevelt and Kennedy were around.

But in this case he is so massively and suddenly ill that its not realistic to cover it up and I think the Irish Times had every right to publish it. It is of genuine public importance now, because you obviously cannot work at that level of illness and we are entitled to know, at that point, the cause.

But did they get the diagnosis right? This is said to be a progressive genetic illness whereas really he looked as right as rain only a few months ago? Its a very surprising diagnosis, personally I think he will take a lot of secrets to his grave...
 
Joined
Feb 13, 2016
Threads
1
Messages
24
Likes
15
#8
I think they will occupy the same spot in Irish history as the Fenians.

But I don't mean that as a mostly positive reference: a lot of Fenians fell into corruption, were cheerfully used as pawns by the British to get coercian acts passed, using a vast network of informers in their ranks, and indeed committed many many terrible completely unjustifiable atrocities.

But still the Fenians did help to keep the flame alive, via some genuinely unselfish and brave people in their ranks, and that was a good thing...
 
Top Bottom